NOTE: FNH is on hiatus for a few months and will feature reposts and limited new material.

General: Food Network, Reader Submitted Posts »

    50 Responses

  1. phoenix2mj says:

    Dear god, what did I just read? This is brilliant.

  2. Pepper says:

    Yesssss. This pleases me.

  3. Ida Slapter says:

    Love this and I’m sure there is a ‘Roy’ out there in Connecticut…

  4. Matt Smith says:

    It says Paula dumped green apples in the vat of lard but ina pulled out donuts…

  5. Foo Young says:

    This guy captures the true essence of these celebrity foodies…..e.g. blood stained, gin soaked carnivores.

    Paula rocks…and so does this piece. More, please.

  6. FuryOfFirestorm says:

    That shit was epic! Especially the part with Giada at the end!

  7. rob says:

    the kid has alot of time on his hands. Like it, very amusing…

  8. Drusilla says:

    I didn’t really find it funny. To each his own, I guess.

  9. NS says:

    Ooookay. I didnt really find this funny. Whatever.

  10. Didi says:

    Creative writing major huh? wow must have been the easiest “A”s ever!

    • Chris says:

      They really are easy. I used creative writing classes as a GPA boost for engineering.

    • Mike says:

      With material like this, it’s a shock the kid graduated. While very creative, I found the entire thing unfunny.

      I suppose there are going to be people who will eat this right up and say its the funnies fanfic theyve ever read about food network personalities, but I just cant say I found this more than mildly entertaining.

  11. PAULA DEENLICIOUS says:

    THIS. IS. INCREDIBLE.

  12. thehip says:

    I think the funny part must have been edited out.

  13. Mal_Pal says:

    not amusing…you could have stuck any names in there.

  14. swopes says:

    Love it. I’m an F&M grad too, so this does us proud!

  15. HookahSmookah says:

    I could sort of see how “deep” he was trying to go, but it didn’t work. For comedy, you need to keep it light.
    It made me feel like the writer hadn’t really watched many of the shows/hosts in question and wrote this on the fly.

    I used to write “Create Your Own Sem-Ho Episodes” on TWop and it was so much fun and I always got rave reviews for humor. I also did recaps of “Alex’s Day Off.” Those always got a laugh, too.

    Now, people actually replicate shows on YouTube, so it takes all of the fun out of it.

  16. Nancy says:

    I hope the author doesn’t submit this as an example of his talent for a job in the field of journalism. It was neither funny nor entertaining and sounded like something a 6th grader would write.

    • Dusty Lee says:

      you know, i was thinking the same thing. i think a kid may have wrote this and lied to jillian about being an older person. it doesn’t really make much sense and i don’t think the person that wrote it really watches the shows. all the cliches are so broad and then there the was the strange “Giada is a werewolf scene” all of a sudden.

      i think i’m just over the whole “paula is an unhealthy cook” thing.

  17. rob-omb says:

    Hmm, needs more making out….

  18. Myname says:

    Disgusting & not funny is not what we want to read here…

  19. daninplano says:

    Yeah. Not so much. I’ve read better. I’m a fan of Paula but this was just too bizarre.

  20. Chris says:

    I really only “laughed” once… when Giada entered:

    Paula looks at the camera.

    PAULA (muttering as she takes a sip): Oh, hell.

    That was cute. Otherwise… not so funny.

  21. Pork Chop says:

    Uh oh…..the humor police are out in force. You know them…..very earnest, sincere, and throughly vegetarian.

    I thought this piece was pretty funny. The portrayals were exaggerated, but accurate enough to ring true at some level. Loved the Ina character…
    actually laughed out loud at some points.

    Keep it up, kid. Take a shot next time at the typical food blog site audience.

  22. Hot Tams says:

    AAAAHAHALHALHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!
    This shit was fucking HILARIOUS!!! PERFECT!!!!

  23. My Name Is Gee says:

    Whoa. Just… whoa.
    I have no idea what I just read.

  24. smrt says:

    Love it! Can’t wait for the movie……

  25. Mrs. Holden says:

    This was absolutely terrible. I don’t think the author should have a creative writing major. At all. The description was sub-par at best and none of it fit together. I’ll admit, it was kind of funny in some spots but overall, I was disappointed.

  26. Robert says:

    It’s called absurdity, people. The humor comes from how strange the story was pushed. The writer hit Paula Deen’s horndog status and love of fat, Ina’s bizarre relationship with Jeffrey and proclivity for only the good ingredients, and Giada’s off-putting attitude and monstrous teeth that could cut a tree in twain. Its not going to appeal to everyone, but it doesn’t mean it’s a bad writing sample.

  27. K says:

    If you’re going to write something that has your real name (and college, for that matter) attached to it, you might want to consider putting a little bit more effort to it next time and add a bit of that ‘creative writing’ flair because this is really awful. It feels like you didn’t really do a good job imitating Ina’s mannerisms. I understand what you were trying to do, but it’s just too far-fetched to be funny. It also reminds me of a bad slash fanfiction or something.

  28. Brii says:

    Oh sweet jebuz! this is fuckin Epic!!

  29. Blue Cheese says:

    I couldn’t even get through this drivel.

  30. Enough. Some of you are being total assholes and I’ve had it. If you don’t think it’s funny, shut up about it. Have some courtesy for the guest poster for Christ’s sake.

    • K says:

      It’d be worse for her not to hear critiques about her work. It’s the only way you can really get an honest opinion, after all. It’s especially important because this is her career choice.

      Besides, isn’t it similar to what you’re doing to the Food Network? Following that logic, if you had just stopped being an asshole and shut up because you didn’t like it then you wouldn’t have a site.

      • It’s completely different. You can criticize me all you want, and you can criticize this person all you want, as long as it’s done constructively. Just saying “THIS SHIT IS STUPID DRIVEL, THIS IS DUMB” is obnoxious and it’s not constructive.

        And this person is a guest here. We encourage work from other posters. FNH is supposed to be a welcoming community… not a bunch of complaining assholes who criticize submitters.

        If you don’t think it’s funny, move on to one of the other 3,000 posts that are here for your viewing pleasure and free of charge.

        • Vespertine says:

          Way to call your readers a bunch of assholes. Don’t have a comments section if you don’t wanna take the good with the bad.

          And I will criticize you for being a complete hypocrite. Why don’t you “move on” to another channel if you obviously can’t stand the food network so much?

          And btw, I actually enjoyed the submission and this blog.. I just didn’t enjoy your policing of people saying what they want about something they don’t like.

          • I didn’t call my readers assholes. I called some of the commenters – who have never commented here before, except to insult this author – a bunch of assholes. And I stand by that.

            Except I’d like to add an addendum and add you to the list and call you an asshole as well.

            Bye!

  31. MD says:

    It definitely had some funny parts to it, made me laugh! Hilarious to add Giada at the end. I agree with Jillian, provide constructive feedback or move on if you disliked it.

  32. author says:

    Hi guys! This is the author of this post. First, I’d like to thank the blog managers for allowing me to darken this site with this piece; I appreciate you taking the time to read my work and taking a chance on me! Second, I’m really glad all of you all took the time to give me your constructive criticism. I just have a few things to comment on:

    YOU’RE RIGHT, ALL OF YOU: I AM A GIRL EVEN THOUGH I’M A BOY (I KNOW, RIGHT? CAREY IS A GIRL’S NAME!!! BUT I AM A MALE PERSON), I’M IN 6TH GRADE, I DIDN’T DESERVE TO GRADUATE COLLEGE, I AM NOT FUNNY, I SHOULD NEVER HAVE ATTACHED MY COLLEGE’S NAME TO THIS GARBAGE OR CHOSEN IT AS A REPRESENTATION OF MY “TALENT” IN THE FIELD OF JOURNALISM EVEN THOUGH I HAVE ZERO DESIRE TO BE IN THE FIELD OF JOURNALISM, I HAVE NO TALENT!!! CREATIVE WRITING IS SUCH AN EASY MAJOR AND YOU JUST GET STRAIGHT A’S AND BASICALLY YOU ARE JUST WASTING AN EDUCATION, THIS PIECE IS NOT FUNNY, THIS IS NOT SURREALIST COMEDY OR ABSURDITY, IT IS JUST DISGUSTING AND NOT FUNNY NOT FUNNY, I HAVE NO FUTURE IN ANYTHING AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

  33. Alixandra says:

    I just wet my pants.

  34. Katch00 says:

    Food Network FanFic!! ARRRGGHHHH!!!

  35. Nubbzy says:

    Lol he has a sense of humor :P Get one! He better be glad his instructor had one, or his ass wouldve failed <3

  36. Nubbzy says:

    **She. And it’s obvious how much work was put into this. Criticism is one thing. Being a dick is an entirely different thing. If you dont think it’s funny, thats your opinion. Calling it drivel, and the author stupid is just demonstrating how closed-minded and idiotic you are. I, for one, was very entertained. My mother wasn’t, but all she said was “Hm, not exactly my style.”. You know, a SENSIBLE comment. I hope when you guys have children, the doctor throws your baby away. Because its not as cute as the last one he delivered. Good day <3

  37. Profit says:

    This had me laughing so hard I was tearing-up… I wish someone would animate this as a flash-toon.

  38. Tyler says:

    Absolutely hilarious! I can just picture the story unfolding on an episode of Paula’s Best Dishes. Great work, Carey O’Donnell.

  39. nucleargirl says:

    Holy shit. unbelievably hilarious.

Post your comments


LEGAL DISCLAIMER / DISCLOSURE/PRIVACY POLICY / Terms of Service
We are not affiliated with the Food Network, or any of their hosts, in any way. This is a satire, humor, and parody website.
(c) 2012 Food Network Humor - All Rights Reserved